North Korea has long had a guilty allure for me — it brings up some squirming contradictions.  So intriguing: the ultimate foreign land, full of strangeness.  We’re all fascinated by it.  But then horrified: the famine, the camps, the death.

Under the rule of Kim Jong-Un, North Korea remains among the world’s most repressive countries. All basic freedoms have been severely restricted under the Kim family’s political dynasty. A 2014 UN Commission of Inquiry found that abuses in North Korea were without parallel in the contemporary world. They include extermination, murder, enslavement, torture, imprisonment, rape, forced abortions, and other sexual violence. North Korea operates secretive prison camps where perceived opponents of the government are sent to face torture and abuse, starvation rations, and forced labor. Fear of collective punishment is used to silence dissent. There is no independent media, functioning civil society, or religious freedom.  

Human Rights Watch

Often the global coverage of North Korea, or the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea as it’s more properly known, tends almost towards humour.  Oh look at those funny North Koreans, what will they get up to next?  You could argue laughter is a weapon, and both factual coverage and fictional portrayals of the Kims have certainly made them look pretty silly.  What power does a regime so mocked really have, you could say.  But satire only works as a weapon from within.  This isn’t the regime’s own people laughing at them, it’s outsiders, and I wonder if all it serves to do is isolate the country and its beleaguered citizens further.  I’m guilty of it too, sometimes the news is so bizarre that it’s hard not to laugh, but it’s a bit odd that we find a country with such an appalling human rights record (not to mention nuclear ambitions) so amusing.

945839_551087311606841_1851970567_n
Inside North Korea

Image from Wait But Why* on facebook.

Actually, looking at pictures from inside North Korea, most of the scenes portrayed could easily be in China or Vietnam.  These countries have personality cults for dead leaders too.  These countries have large portions of their population living in rural poverty.  They don’t have forced labour camps, but they don’t have political and religious freedom either.  China has secret detention centres, and it’s likely similar horrors occur there as in North Korea.  And yes China and Vietnam have internet, but it’s heavily restricted and effectively edited by the government.  Plus, what you do online can get you into serious trouble in real life.  Vietnam has more communist propaganda billboards than you can shake a hammer and sickle at.  (We saw a good portion of them when we cycled the length of Vietnam.)

IMG_2257
A common scene in Vietnam.

Of course North Korea is cruel to its people, but in some ways it’s not all that unusual.  My point is that we let our perception of North Korea as somewhere unreal and other colour our perception of everything we learn about it.  Much of life there seems to be pretty ordinary.  Poor and undernourished and difficult, but ordinary in that.

So, to visit or not to visit?  Some argue that visiting can only help: North Koreans will see the rest of the world is different, visitors will see what it’s really like, and the world won’t forget.  Money will come into the country, helping hungry people.  Others argue that visiting condones the regime, that visits are so tightly controlled that locals and visitors learn nothing of each other, and that money spent goes to prop up the regime and the wealthy.  Interestingly, opinion among those who have fled North Korea is just as divided as among outsiders, though it seems to tend slightly towards ‘don’t go’.

I’m inclined towards the latter view, though by no means decided.  My gut says that going in the only way currently available, government controlled tours, amounts to tacit agreement with the regime.  But then you meet people who’ve been, as we did on the Trans Siberian railway, and they rave about their trip.  I was a little disconcerted by how keen one guy we met was on the DPRK actually, I think he may have used the phrase ‘it’s actually really nice’.  Reading the Lonely Planet North Korea (yes, that’s a thing**) made me really want to go, as reading the Lonely Planet for almost anywhere does.  But it’s got a few unsettling phrases in it.

If you had any doubt that your trip to North Korea would keep you in dinner party anecdotes for decades to come, the Kumusan memorial palace will quash them.

Lonely Planet

You can’t read that and not question your own reasons for wanting to visit.

I’m ashamed to say that ultimately, in this instance, budget was the real decider.  Tightly planned, heavily escorted tours, which only use private transport and tourist approved hotels, don’t come cheap.

But the place has such a draw, so what to do?

Visit the DMZ, the Korean Demilitarised Zone.

dprk_soldier
A DPRK soldier points out the DMZ.

Image from Kristoferb on Wikipedia, licensed under Creative Commons.

The demilitarised zone is the heavily militarised (!) tightly monitored buffer of land between two countries still technically (sort of, not really) at war.  A visit to the DMZ affords you the opportunity to step onto North Korean soil (carpet actually), briefly and relatively safely, and have a good gawp at North Korea from the border.  And critically, visit the DMZ from the South and none of your money will go to North Korea.

So this is what we did — you can read about our very odd day out to the DMZ here.

Would you visit North Korea?  It’s a tricky one — I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.


*Tim Urban from Wait But Why went to North Korea, and wrote a simultaneously hilarious and thoughtful post about it here.  Highly recommended reading.

**Well, actually it’s a chapter in Lonely Planet Korea.  And it’s very odd reading, as it’s got no practical information whatsoever in it.  Guess there’s no point when you can’t visit independently.  I imagine they’d struggle to fill a whole book with just North Korea, given most of the ‘sights’ are statues or museums, and there are only about 3 restaurants listed.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Should I visit North Korea?

  1. North Korea used to be a sort of bucket list country for me, and it still fascinates me, but I feel less inclined to visit nowadays due to many of the points you mentioned. The money would go into fuelling a government I in no world would support, and it’s not the ‘real’ NK is it? Still, would be an incredible experience, but right now by answer is a no, I wouldn’t go.

    Like

    1. I think that’s pretty much where I am too, if I imagine somebody offered me a free trip I think I would turn it down (imagining something has already happened is my go to way to decide if I want it to happen). Have you seen this British vlogger is getting vilified for making happy holiday in North Korea videos? (http://www.vanityfair.com/culture/2016/08/louis-cole-vlogger-north-korea) It made me feel a bit sick watching him ignore all the horror and make it look like a super hip off the beaten track destination. But that’s the reality of going there now: a totally false impression. Hopefully change will come, and then it’ll be possible to visit and have a great experience that might do some good. (Clearly change is most important for North Koreans… I am vaguely aware that my holiday plans are not the most important thing in the world.)

      Myanmar used to be on my list of places that I would love to visit but couldn’t justify ethically, but then in the last four years or so, all change. It was such a great experience going there and we learnt so much from chatting to people, even though the politics there is still pretty off.

      Weirdly, China used to be on this list too, but at some point I sort of gave up thinking it made any difference if I went or not. Somehow it just didn’t feel like it mattered. Perhaps because their economy is so huge anyway, and I thought most of their foreign income probably comes from exports. Illogical probably.

      Like

  2. I have read a small bit about travelling and while people argue that you are just giving them money for a tour where you don’t get to see the ‘real’ North Korea, you have to also remember if you don’t pay the money then someone else will. I think it would be interesting to be able to finally view the country for yourself as opposed to from behind a screen or book. Personally if I have the money, I think I would like to see for myself what the country has to offer (fake or otherwise). Even if is all staged, it would most certainly be interesting!

    Like

    1. Yes, absolutely, would definitely be a unique and interesting experience. It’s still quite an off the beaten track destination at the moment, I think only about 5000 non-Chinese visitors go each year, though many many more Chinese do. Possibly because several tourists have been imprisoned in the last few years, including an American this year. (https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/16/north-korea-sentences-us-student-to-15-years-hard-labour) I suppose my main worry is that visiting could do more harm than good if the money only benefits the regime. Also, I don’t know if I could stop myself asking awkward questions/contradicting the truth according to North Korea. Tourists behaving badly has potential to be very very serious for their North Korean tour guides safety, if not their own. The mass games do look amazing though, totally unique and bizarre.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply. Thoughts and feedback much appreciated!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s